Growth, balanced or conservative? How to pick your KiwiSaver fund by age and goal
KiwiSaver funds are usually grouped into types: defensive, conservative, balanced, growth and high growth. The difference comes down to the mix of two kinds of assets they hold. Income assets (cash and bonds) tend to move less in either direction. Growth assets (shares and property) tend to move more in either direction.
- Defensive and conservative funds hold mostly income assets: cash and bonds.
- Balanced funds sit roughly in between, with a mix of both.
- Growth and high growth funds hold mostly growth assets: shares and property.
- The name describes the asset mix. It isn't a judgement on the fund itself.
Growth
Mostly shares. Built for long timeframes, with the biggest swings along the way.
Balanced
A middle mix of shares and bonds. Moderate swings, moderate long-run growth.
Conservative
Mostly bonds and cash. Smaller swings, and a lower expected return over time.
The trade-off runs one way. More growth assets have tended to produce higher returns over long periods, in exchange for bigger swings, including real falls, over any single year or few years. More income assets have tended to produce smoother, more modest returns over the same long periods, with far fewer sharp drops along the way. Both sides carry a cost: more growth means accepting a genuinely bad year is possible, less growth means accepting a lower expected return over decades.
- High Growth8% average, 16% volatility
- Growth7% average, 13% volatility
- Balanced6% average, 9% volatility
- Conservative4.5% average, 5% volatility
- Defensive3.5% average, 3% volatility
- Risk vs return: more growth assets have tended to mean higher long-run returns, with more risk of a bad year along the way.
- Time: money needed in a few years has less time to recover from a fall than money you won't touch for decades.
- Ups and downs: growth-heavy funds can drop sharply in a single year. Income-heavy funds tend to move less, both up and down.
There's no one right fund type for everyone. An adviser can help you work out which fund type suits you, or you can run your numbers through the KiwiSaver Health Check.